I Heart Peer Pressure, However Dull
On what was basically a whim about 10 years ago, over 10 years ago, actually, I joined my first songwriter group. I bumped into an old friend who knew a guy who was in a songwriting group. And we got to talking, ’cause he was with the guy. And I just said yes.
The first group of songs were horrible. The second group of songs were less horrible. And the frequency of good ones increased with time. I’ve done over 20 rounds with that group and other groups. I’ve done a song a day for three or four years in a row in January.
I can absolutely positively guarantee you that the reps and those kind of groups work because of, you know, somebody’s watching. Doesn’t matter who, doesn’t matter what. You don’t want to get addicted to the feedback, but it absolutely works. So, thinking that it doesn’t work is off the table. It is the thing, and it works. Period, end of story.
So I wanted to offer some advice. I don’t do it often, or I don’t do it purposely often, but I probably do it a lot, on things to do and not to do.
Always finish. Finish everything you start. Don’t move on to the next idea. Just realize that this is the song that’s coming to you this week and get it done. Or that day, however you’re doing it. But just finish that thing. That is super important, to learn how to finish a song.
Next, you really need to learn how to record it somehow. Your phone works. So in essence, you already know how to record it. What you’re going to have to do is figure out how to position whatever you’re writing with and your big old mouth. Those are the barriers to entry. The biggest thing is actually doing it.
So, what not to do is equally as important. You can’t get something done or you don’t like what you got done that week? Great. Don’t explain it to the group. No one cares. No one cares if you’re not showing up this week. Don’t apologize. It’s so inelegant. Or if you don’t like what you did but turned it in anyway, don't turn this into story time. Vomit emoji.
Again, no one cares. Like, zero people.
It has been my experience that no one group cares less about your music than other musicians. And that’s the problem with, like, musician support groups.
They are a paradox.
All of them are sitting around talking about each other’s music and getting pissed off and jealous. So, use these groups as a way to write, but don’t think you’re gonna, you know, get anywhere with these other people. Because they’re just as bad as you. Obviously, you want your song to be the best, and in some (a/k/a most) cases, their song to be the worst. It’s better to be honest about it now.
Pretty soon, you’ll be able to develop a bullshit meter on yourself and be able to figure out when you’ve launched a turd, or you’ve got something with potential.
The last thing I’ll say is, when you do get good feedback, make note of it. But don’t, like, take it to the bank. If that makes any sense. Like, it’s great that you got the feedback. Sometimes, I don’t know, maybe some people are just being nice and trying to encourage a new person. But, you know, don’t quit your day job. It takes time. You’ll figure out what your odds are.
When I write songs with words, out of ten, I’ve got maybe two. I’d say three, but the third has to be cut. And it typically will come sixth, seventh, or eighth. Again, don’t quote me on that, and it’s always different for me, but generally, I can depend on that. Which you’ll be able to do the same once you’ve done enough of these.
So, if you get a chance, do it, and keep whatever you can to yourself, because no one cares. But everyone cares just the same.
Hugs.